After weeks of voting (and more than a few heated slice debates), the results are in—and FoCo has spoken. You cast your votes for everything from wood-fired wonders to late-night legends, and now we’re serving up the official top 10 pizza joints in town. Whether you’re in it for the crust, the cheese, or just an excuse to eat your feelings with garlic knots, this list has something for every pizza personality.

Here’s how it shook out:

🥇 1. JJ’s Wood Fired Pizza

📍 4015 S Taft Hill Rd

A neighborhood favorite for a reason. JJ’s pairs crispy wood-fired pies with hearty pastas, fresh salads, and meatballs made from family recipes. Cozy vibes, solid portions, and a crust that crunches just right.

🥈 2. Krazy Karl’s

📍 Multiple Locations

Beloved by students and longtime locals alike, Krazy Karl’s keeps things fun with late-night hours, wild topping combos, and weekly specials. Bonus points if you’ve had their “cream cheese crust” and lived to tell the tale.

🥉 3. PizzaVino NoCo Italiano

📍 Bucking Horse

Wine + pizza + pasta = yes, please. This family-owned Italian spot brings a little taste of Italy to Northern Colorado with a refined menu and romantic patio seating that’s perfect for your next pizza date night.

4. Slyce Pizza Co.

📍 163 W Mountain Ave

Slyce is a late-night legend in Old Town, slinging creative slices (mac & cheese pizza, anyone?) until the wee hours. Their by-the-slice counter is fast, fun, and full of flavor—and the local love runs deep.

5. Fuego Pizza Company

📍 2601 S Lemay Ave

“In Crust We Trust,” says Fuego—and FoCo agrees. This spot brings the heat with fire-kissed pies, bold flavor combos, and a passion for quality ingredients. Grab a slice, hang with friends, and let the crust do the talking. 🔥

Rounding out the top 10 are some local gems that deserve their own pizza praise. The Corner Slice and Pizza Casbah tied for 6th, both dishing up bold flavors and loyal followings—whether you’re craving a classic New York slice or a creative pie with attitude. Beau Jo’s (8th place) keeps things Colorado-authentic with their signature “Mountain Pies” and honey for the crust. Cozzola’s Pizza landed at 9th with their no-fuss, neighborhood-style pies perfect for carryout nights. And in 10th, Totally 80’s Pizza & Museum brings the nostalgia and the cheese—because who doesn’t want a side of VHS tapes and vintage arcade games with their pepperoni?

Wednesday, October 15

Thursday, October 16